Should you see an individual therapist for relationship problems?
Discover why individual therapy often fails for relationship problems and can make things worse. Learn when couples therapy is the better choice for relational issues. Sydney-based insights.

Dr Rowan Burckhardt
Founder and director
Clinical psychologist
More people than ever are seeking therapy, which represents genuine progress in how we approach emotional wellbeing. Yet this increase in therapy use has created an unexpected challenge: many people turn to individual therapists for relationship difficulties, not realising this approach can sometimes make things worse rather than better.
The double-edged sword of increased therapy access
The past decade has transformed how we view mental health support. People now openly discuss their struggles and seek professional guidance without the shame that once surrounded therapy. Psychologists have seen demand surge, and the internet provides unprecedented access to psychological information.
This shift has helped countless people understand problematic patterns, process trauma, recognise neurodivergent traits, and develop coping skills. People feel less isolated, more understood, and better equipped to manage life’s challenges.
Yet this progress has created an unintended consequence for relationships.
The pattern that keeps appearing in couples therapy
After years of working with couples, a concerning pattern has emerged. Someone struggles with something in their relationship. Perhaps it’s a single incident or a long-standing behaviour. The person feels emotionally affected and seeks help from an individual therapist.
The therapist listens. They may validate how unacceptable the behaviour seems. They might discuss boundaries. Sometimes they label the partner as emotionally abusive or suggest narcissistic traits. The client feels better initially. The relationship suffers or breaks down instead of being repaired.
Why individual therapy can harm relationships
The one-sided story problem
When working individually, therapists hear only one perspective. Stories always sound worse when you hear just one side. The therapist naturally feels empathy for their client and outrage toward the person causing pain. They don’t hear the other partner’s suffering, which is often equal but stems from different sources.
This isn’t about one person downplaying their role. We genuinely struggle to see our impact on others. Relationships stir our strongest feelings, which magnifies the effect of hearing only one perspective.
The innocent victim narrative
Individual therapy can entrench the view that one person is the innocent victim while the other behaves inappropriately. This becomes dangerous because couples therapy works by helping each partner see how they impact the other and contribute to painful patterns.
When someone arrives at couples therapy already convinced they’re blameless, healing becomes far more difficult.
The lost opportunity for shared growth
Yes, one person shares their suffering in individual therapy. But their partner suffers too. When both partners can share their pain together, they create opportunities for mutual growth and deeper understanding. Individual therapy eliminates this possibility.

Why individual therapy strategies don't work for intimate relationships
Individual therapists naturally suggest individual strategies because that’s their training focus. These strategies might include:
•
Setting firm boundaries
•
Protecting yourself or children
•
Clearly stating how unacceptable behaviour is
•
Demanding specific changes
•
Labelling problematic behaviour
•
Creating distance
•
Considering separation
These approaches may work for relationships with colleagues or extended family members. For intimate partnerships, they often fail because they don’t account for the other partner’s feelings and rarely lead to lasting change.
How relationship work differs from individual work
Working with relationships requires different tools than working with individuals. You need to understand how each person impacts the other. You need approaches suited to being in love with someone, caring deeply about them, while struggling with certain behaviours. Most importantly, you need tools both partners can use simultaneously.
The boundary example
Consider Jane, who wants to maintain a friendship with Luke. Her partner John feels uncomfortable because Luke has shown romantic interest previously. Jane insists she has no feelings for Luke and doesn’t think John should control who she sees.
If Jane applies individual therapy boundaries, she might tell John he can’t dictate her friendships. She might label him as controlling or jealous, suggesting he needs to work on these issues.
But what if John also applies boundaries, believing you shouldn’t spend time alone with someone who has romantic feelings for you when in a committed relationship?
Some people might agree with Jane. Others with John. What about going away for the weekend together? Or sharing accommodation? We all draw different lines about what’s acceptable.
The problem isn’t about whose boundaries are right. John and Jane need a way to resolve their different perspectives. This requires couples therapy, not competing boundary declarations.
When individual therapy makes sense
Individual therapy serves important purposes. It helps with personal struggles, past trauma, anxiety, depression, and self-understanding. For individual challenges, it’s often exactly what’s needed.
The issue arises when relationship difficulties get treated as individual problems. A well-trained couples therapist understands relational dynamics and won’t risk the damage that can occur when individual therapy amplifies feelings of indignation and entrenches the view that the other person is the problem.
Making the right choice
If you’re struggling in your relationship, consider whether the issue stems from individual challenges or relational patterns. Individual therapy works for individual problems. Relationship problems require different tools, different understanding, and an approach that honours both partners’ experiences.
The goal isn’t to assign blame or determine who’s right. The goal is to understand the patterns keeping you stuck and develop new ways of connecting that work for both of you.
“Relationship problems require relational solutions. Individual therapy can help you understand yourself, but couples therapy helps both partners understand the patterns keeping the relationship stuck.”
Your next step
If you’ve been considering individual therapy for relationship struggles, pause and reflect. Are you seeking validation that you’re right and your partner is wrong? Or are you genuinely hoping to transform how you connect? The answer to that question points you toward the support that will actually help.
Relationship healing requires courage from both partners. It means being willing to see your own impact, not just your partner’s behaviour. It means developing tools together, not strategies that protect you from each other.
If you’re ready to understand what’s really happening in your relationship and work toward genuine change, couples therapy provides the framework individual therapy simply cannot offer.